A tankless unit heats water as it passes through a heat exchanger, so there is no stored hot water, no standby loss and no tank to rust from the inside. Those are real advantages, and they come with real requirements the building has to meet.
How it changes the gas question
A tank unit fires at a modest input and stores the result. A tankless unit has to raise the water temperature at the moment of demand, which means a much higher input, often several times the tank's. The gas line has to carry that, and the meter and service have to allow it.
This is the most common reason a conversion costs more than expected. An undersized gas line produces a unit that derates, throws an error, or delivers lukewarm water at high flow, and fixing it after the fact means opening walls.
Venting is a different category
Tankless units typically use Category III or IV venting: stainless or polypropylene, with their own clearances and, in condensing models, a condensate drain that has to go somewhere with a slope and a neutralisation path where required. The old tank's flue cannot usually be reused, and a sidewall termination has clearance rules of its own.
Demand and temperature rise
Sizing is a flow question, not a house-size question. A unit is rated for a temperature rise at a flow rate; in winter the incoming water is colder, so the same unit delivers less hot water. Two showers running at once is the case that separates an adequate unit from an impressive spec sheet.
Where the demand is genuinely high, the answer is often two units, staged, rather than one larger unit, which also gives some redundancy when one needs service.
Hard water is the maintenance schedule
San Gabriel Valley Water Company's 2025 report lists hardness averaging 234 ppm, with samples to 280 ppm. In a tank, that hardness settles as sediment. In a tankless unit, it coats the heat exchanger, and the exchanger is the expensive part.
Descaling, which means circulating a mild acid through the unit, is the maintenance that keeps the exchanger alive, and on very hard water it belongs on a schedule rather than on a reaction to a fault code. Many units also have an inlet filter that has to be cleaned more often than the manual's default suggests.
What else changes
A tankless unit needs power for its controls and fan, which means a circuit; it may need a condensate path; and it may need clearances from a window, a door or a neighbouring property line at the vent termination. In a garage, the same ignition-source elevation rule applies.
When tankless is the right answer
Where space is genuinely tight, where hot water demand is concentrated rather than simultaneous, or where the building already has the gas capacity. It is a poor fit where the gas service is marginal, where the water is very hard and nobody will maintain the unit, or where the household wants the lowest installed cost.
When it is not
A conversion that needs a gas service upgrade, a new vent through a finished wall and an electrical circuit can cost several times a straight tank replacement. That is not a reason to refuse it. It is a reason to price it before the decision rather than after.